Fun Competition - Lil'Hero vs Scrapie

[Scrapie]

So, we decided to do a little fun competition Vote for the image you like most ! If you want comment, go ahead

Deadline for voting is Sunday the 28th November =)

[Maffe811]

Q: How do you get images in the poll ?

[David Wood]

Both of these are very nice, I'm not sure which one to pick.

Lil' Hero:

The smudging is nice but I can see some repetition. Her body shouldn't be blurred so much, it's at the same depth as her face. Also not all of her, um. . . chest is blurred. Her wings could be blended better. Some c4ds and effects would be a nice touch and one should be in front to add additional depth. Also more complimentary color would be nice.

Scrapie:

Nice smudging also. Where the focal is smudged or blurred is pretty good but the blurring could be less. The flow is goofy, it should be vertical to match the render but instead the lightning smudges are intersecting this. This makes them very distracting. The transition between blue and orange could be better. Light source is also too visible, it should be pushed off to the side more. Some c4ds would be nice.

I pick - Scrapie.

---------


@Maffe He added this to the poll options.

Code: Select all

[img]http://www.scrapiefx.net/Comp/LilHeroComp.png[/img] - Lil'Hero
[img]http://www.scrapiefx.net/Comp/ScrapieComp.png[/img] - Scrapie

[Maffe811]

i did not now you could use bbcode in polls

[David Wood]

Me neither.

[Arzoroc]

Lil's is too blurry at the bottom in my opinion

[RomaGrafix]

Lil's is too blurry at the bottom in my opinion

agreed, and the smudging looks weird, looks like the spacing on the brush was too high, that one could have been pretty cool..my vote for scrapie too though

[Scrapie]

I guess, this is over =| Do I have to gratulate myself? I won't, feels wrong

Can sb. lock it?

[David Wood]

Wait, Lil' hero never posted in this thread, I want to know what he thought of our cnc.

[Lil'Hero]

sorry for the late reaction have a stage i dunno how to call that in english so im very busy but thx for cnc i know but i was to lazy to sharpen again but the overal of scrapie was a lil bit better

[Maffe811]

Now we can gratz Scrapie ?

[Slayed]

they were both awesome but I like scrapies too - epic smudging

[virtualTune]

i didnt like either but i preferred scrapies due to etter lighting

[A Psycho Martyr]

I voted for Scrapie, but simplt because I'm not into the girly images.
It was done well, just not my taste.

[Maffe811]

Scrapie's smudges are prefabs (made by him) dl link anyone ?