Since you called me awesome, i will try to comment on every single one of them.
Casper wrote:
What most beguinners do, is that they make really decent sigs, but they finish it to early.
Like this is a brilliant starting point.
A1. Don't add text.
You shouldn't add text until you have fully mastered the other elements.
Alot of good sig makers hasn't mastered text fully, and therefore leaves it out.
You should do this, atleast in the start.
A2. Only 1 focal.
In this case its two pices of text and one render.
It could aslo be the thing in the bottom left corner.
A3. Focus/Depth
Try making the render be the point of focus.
Example: Take the blur/sharpen tool on low rate with the fuzzy brush and gently blur areas you wan't to take the focus away from.
Doing this can also create depth. Fake the feeling that some things are farther away than others.
Depth can be used to create focus.
These doesn't got alot.
They got a cartoon render, so alot of the usuall elements does not need to apply.
Also, on the castle crushers, they are a little stretched/squished.
They are scaled more down/up then left/right.
Therefore looks squished. Try to avoid this at all cost!
+ Same as A1
Casper wrote:
A1 + A2 +A3
Casper wrote:
This seem to need the text cause its got that slogan thing.
You should therefore try to find a good text effect that could fork with the theme.
Also the red doesn't go with the Render
+ A1 (+ A2) +A3
Casper wrote:
This is a sig where you can really see that two focals make it all... wierd
It is also really empty!
+ A1 + A2 +A3
----------------------------
I hope i wasn't to harsh, but if you wanna improve, we gotta tell it like it is.
But you should try reading some tutorials for novices and advanced users.
Try to lay off the text for a while.
Maybe look for a depth and a lighting tutorial.
Even though lighting can be done with a radial white to black gradient put on overlay.
